Argument Analysis: Guantanamo Bay

1669 Words7 Pages
Guantanamo Bay Bobbi Brown POL 201 Robert Paixao December 10, 2012 Guantanamo Bay was built in Cuba in 2002 by the Bush Administration to be used as a detention center to imprison people that are believed to be involved with the war in Afghanistan and then later in Iraq. However, there is no actual proof as to which detainees are really involved and believed to be terrorist, and which are not, because it is out of the legal jurisdiction of the United States to enforce the writ of habeas corpus (Foley, 2007). Habeas Corpus is a writ, or a legal action, that allows a person who is under arrest the right to be brought in front of a judge or into court. This then allows the person who is under arrest to be released…show more content…
Some may believe that continuing to detain prisoners who are no longer threats to the United States is undesirable and is unlikely to persuade the rest of the world of our good intentions. Other people may believe that releasing prisoners who are in fact intend to commit violence or danger against the United States or to rejoin the ranks of those fighting our military is also undesirable. It will always be a battle of arguments, but the only way to prove if one is so called guilty or innocent, is to give them the right to a fair trial (Yin,…show more content…
Restoring Habeas Corpus: An Analysis of Boumediene v. Bush. Retrieved from: http://www.afj.org/assets/resources/cases/boumediene-analysis.pdf Ardiente, M. (2006). EVERYTHING BUT THE TRUTH: Allegations of Abuse and Torture at Guantanamo Bay. (Cover story). Humanist, 66(1), 16-18. CCR (n.d). Factsheet: Boumediene v. Bush/Al Odah v. U.S.:The Supreme Court Decision. Retrieved from: http://ccrjustice.org/learn-more/faqs/factsheet-boumediene Foley, B. J. (2007). GUANTANAMO AND BEYOND: DANGERS OF RIGGING THE RULES. Journal Of Criminal Law & Criminology, 97(4), 1009-1069. GPO (2006). Military Commissions Act. Retrieved from: http://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/BILLS-109s3930enr/pdf/BILLS-109s3930enr.pdf Hall, M. (2009). Obama: Bush-era polices have weakened national security. Retrieved from: http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/t/story?id=7647588&page=1 Yin, T. (2005). ENDING THE WAR ON TERRORISM ONE TERRORIST AT A TIME: A NONCRIMINAL DETENTION MODEL FOR HOLDING AND RELEASING GUANTANAMO BAY DETAINEES. Harvard Journal Of Law & Public Policy, 29(1),

More about Argument Analysis: Guantanamo Bay

Open Document