Ancient History - Parthenon Marbles

3449 Words14 Pages
Parthenon Marbles| Cultural Ownership: Parthenon Marbles | Amanda Hormoz | Ms Claveria | | PART A: REMEMBER AND UNDERSTAND: Sources 6.2 & 6.3 Questions: What are the main arguments for the return of the marbles in source 6.2? The main arguments shown in source 6.2 are that whoever owns the marbles is irrelevant and unimportant. The source also believes that the marbles should be returned so they can be placed in the Marbles original site to be displayed with the sculptures displayed alongside the background of the Parthenon Marbles. What arguments for retaining the marbles does the British Museum offer in source 6.3? The argument stated in Source 6.3 is that the Parthenon marbles have been in the British Museum for much longer than where they stood originally in Greece. The source also shows examples that they have become a part of Britain’s heritage and have been centred focus for the European culture and civilization for people’s admiration in the culture of Greece. What, in your opinion is the strongest argument presented by each source? Which is the weakest argument in each case? The strongest argument presented is source 6.2 because it shows you why they should come back to Greece and what will happen when the sculptures have been returned back to Greece. Another reason why I believe it’s the strongest is because it shows why it should be returned back to the original siting. The weakest one is Source 6.3 because it doesn’t have many reasons as to why the marbles should be kept in Britain. See if you can classify the various arguments presented in these two sources into any of the following categories: factual, legal, ethical or moral, specious, spurious. Justify your choices. I think the sources shown are factual because in Source 6.2 it shows exactly what will happen when the Parthenon Marbles are returned back to Greece and then in
Open Document