The Conditions of England 1815-1853 1a) Compare Sources C and D as Evidence for Views on the Tolpuddle Case of 1834

803 Words4 Pages
It appears that both these sources have contrasting opinions on the Tolpuddle case of 1834 although they do believe that the wage issue was not the main problem. Also, they both agree that the control of the workforce and the right to join a Union was the real issue involved in the Tolpuddle case of 1834. Frampton mentioned in source C that labourers were only ‘waiting to join the Union as soon’ as it was legal and that they would not face any ‘punishment’ for their actions against the farmers. Loveless in source D corroborates this as he brought up the fact that they were threatened ‘transportation to any who joined a union’ and as the ’Friendly Society’ was formed beforehand Loveless and the rest of the Tolpuddle Martyrs (so they were known as) were charged for swearing unlawful oaths. Due to the growing number of labourers wanting to join trade unions, organisations were created. The Grand National Consolidated Trade Union (GNCTU) for example was set up in early 1834 in an attempt to form a Grand National union only open to trade unionists. Overall both these sources show that Loveless and Frampton did not share the same view on the Tolpuddle case of 1834. Loveless in source D claimed that it was the first time he heard about a law ‘forbidding such societies’ and unjust methods were used against them in order to suppress them. By this he meant that the Unlawful Oaths Act of 1797, which had been introduced to deal with a naval mutiny, was manipulated in order to make it apply to the oaths to join a civil Friendly Society, this led to ‘placards’ being displayed to oppose the Tolpuddle Martyrs which resulted in them being arrested and found guilty at court then later transported to Australia to prevent any other trade unions being formed. On the other hand in source C Frampton indicates that the labourers were informed that Judge sated that unions could not be

More about The Conditions of England 1815-1853 1a) Compare Sources C and D as Evidence for Views on the Tolpuddle Case of 1834

Open Document