Reconstruction Was a Tragic Failure. Do You Agree?

1411 Words6 Pages
When answering this question, one must ensure that they tackle both aspects of it- firstly, whether or not Reconstruction was a ‘failure,’ and secondly, whether or not it was ‘tragic.’ This essay argues that although Reconstruction led to some positives for blacks, like the vote, increased power, influence and education, ultimately Reconstruction was a tragic failure because it left a legacy of racism that continued in America that can still be felt today and caused the deaths and economic subjugation of many. Firstly, the successes of Reconstruction- one of the clearest successes was the fact that blacks were no longer slaves. Lincoln issued the Emancipation Proclamation in September 1862, which did not free all slaves, but was nonetheless a sign to abolitionists that slavery’s days were limited. Following this, the Republicans were determined to pass a constitutional amendment prohibiting slavery. After Lincoln’s re-election in November 1864 Lincoln pressed for the Congressional approval for the measure (the “Thirteenth Amendment”) and it was passed on 31st January 1865. Being free was not enough for former blacks however to be true citizens of the United States, they needed an organisation that would protect their rights, and so in March 1865 Congress created the Freedmen’s Bureau, which set up public schools, provided aid to the poor, secured equal rights for white Unionists and blacks in the courts, negotiated labour contracts between freedmen and their former masters etc. “The death rate among freedmen was reduced, and sanitary conditions improved.” To see just what a leap this was, one has only to look back at the ante-bellum period, when Southern leaders were able to protect their sectional interests during the Constitutional Convention of 1787, preventing the insertion of any explicit anti-slavery position in the Constitution, and at the
Open Document