Is It a Sort of Humanity for Shylock to Deserve Such an Outcome in Terms of Mercy from Antonio in the Trial at the End of the Story?

349 Words2 Pages
Is it a sort of humanity for Shylock to deserve such an outcome in terms of mercy for Antonio in the trial at the end of the story? Shylock has to change his own religion from Jewish to Christianity in order to maintain his current wealth and property so that he can continue making his living in Venice. He has made such a great decision against his own will since he doesn’t have any choice, therefore he is totally at Antonio’s mercy. According to the story setting, it is the best solution to solve the case. As Shylock should have shown his mercy to Antonio at first, however, he didn’t seize the golden opportunity to forgive Antonio all because of hatred and revenge which is pretty normal in the position of Shylock. I think Shylock’s initial response to Antonio’s arrogance is reasonable since he is also a human being, trying to protect his dignity and respect from others. The trial for Shylock is not so justified in a sense of humanity. What Shylock is seeking is the proper repayment from Antonio, who in turn breaks his agreement first. How the Duke has settled the case is not basing on the rule of law and justice, which is replaced by mercy. Hence, the final judgment is a cruel lesson to Shylock. I don’t believe that Shylock is such a `cold-blooded’ person as he takes commitment, promise and bonding into his considerations. For instance, he is angry when he finds that his daughter has traded the ring given by his wife for entertainment. In this situation, he regards respects for others, which shows his real human nature. In return, he should deserve respects from others. At the end of the story, he has to accept the decision which is totally against his will and more importantly, humanity. I think humanity and mercy should be two separate matters. In conclusion, I don’t regard it is a sort of humanity for Shylock to deserve

More about Is It a Sort of Humanity for Shylock to Deserve Such an Outcome in Terms of Mercy from Antonio in the Trial at the End of the Story?

Open Document