Do You Agree with That View That, in the Years 1964-70, the Labour Government’s Failures Outweighed Its Successes?

295 Words2 Pages
Do you agree with that view that, in the years 1964-70, the Labour Government’s failures outweighed its successes? Explain your answer using the sources and own knowledge (40 marks). Source A agrees with the statement that, in the years 1964-70, the Labour Government’s failures outweighed it successes, and that “all its achievements were not enough” to make up for the damage caused. It goes on to give evidence, for example “key industries […] continued to shrink” and this “caused unemployment to rise”. It is true that in 1964 400,000 people were unemployed and this rose to “just over 600,000 by 1970”, the end of Wilson’s time as Prime Minister. On the other hand, the Source does say that “perhaps from its last year in office”, Labour did make many successful policies, possibly referring to the Equal Pay Act of May 1970. It fails to acknowledge of the other grounding breaking social reforms that were introduced under Wilson’s rule, such as the Sexual Offences Act and Abortion Act of 1967, which has been done in Source B. Also, the Source says that Wilson’s Government made the “same mistakes as the Conservatives”, which suggests that six years in parliament is not enough to undo the mistakes previously made. One could infer from this that it was inevitable that Labour’s failures would outweigh their successes, as it would have happened to whatever party was voted into parliament in 1964. In relation to the question, Source A definitely agrees with the view that, in the years 1964-70, the Labour Government’s failures outweighed it successes but it also gives a one sided view of the situation, which means it as not as valuable to the historian as it does not give a balanced, objective
Open Document