What Are the Strengths and Weaknesses of the Williams' Thesis?

3045 Words13 Pages
What are the Strengths and Limitations of the Williams Thesis that Argues the Abolition of Slavery was Connected to the Rise of Capitalism? For over a century after the abolition of slavery, the mere mention of it resulted in thoughts of selfless, moral abolitionists, such as Wilberforce. Abolition’s centenary was celebrated in Hull (Wilberforce’s hometown) as a shameless homage to Wilberforce’s character and achievements as an abolitionist. The bicentenary of emancipation, however, passed far more quietly in Hull, due largely to the works of Eric E. Williams.[1] His controversial and groundbreaking thesis ‘Capitalism and Slavery’ was widely acclaimed amongst scholars and made the traditional, Whig analysis of the British slave trade and its abolition near impossible to consider.[2] Although thorough study of his work has shown cracks in the credibility of his argument, his style of thinking was, with no doubt, revolutionary and exposed an alternate method of analysing abolition, which was through the needs of the economy. He highlighted that European slaves were being used widely before Caribbean slaves, and the reasoned why the Caribbean was chosen, for the geographical and economic benefits of colonising the Caribbean for sugar slavery (rather than it being a racially motivated decision). He did not deny the presence of racial prejudice in the sugar slave trade, but he said that that racism was a product of slavery, not a reason for it. Williams’ argument that slavery allowed the British economy to undergo its Industrial Revolution is well evidenced, just as his claim that the abolition of slavery was only allowed because slavery was no longer profitable. However, although the strengths of William’s work are undeniable, it is a work in progress. Through his determination to emphasise the economic influence in the abolition of slavery, he undermines and
Open Document