This Is No Case of Petty Right or Wrong

648 Words3 Pages
The poem “This is no case of petty right or wrong” looks at many different feelings about England. These include the jingoist and patriotic views of the media, Thomas’ exploration of a more neutral attitude towards the war and the country, and ultimately his own feelings about England, which the quotation “I am one in crying, God save England, lest we lose what never slaves and cattle blessed” seems to epitomise. At the beginning of the poem “This is no case of petty right or wrong” Thomas presents other people’s feelings towards England, focusing particularly on the jingoist view of the majority of people. “Beside my hate for one fat patriot, my hatred of the Kaiser is love true”. Thomas emphasises his hatred of patriots, by suggesting that he hates them so much that he could love the Kaiser. He also suggests that these patriots grow “hot with love of Englishmen” to “please newspapers”, offering that patriots have almost a false love for their country, as they only love England as to please the newspapers, and therefore have a blind loyalty to England. The beginning of the poem therefore has an almost contemptuous, scornful, angry tone. This is emphasised by the structure of the poem, as it is written in blank verse, and the lack of punctuation together with this gives the feeling of the poem being like a rant, and him expressing his thoughts and opinions. It can also be seen a response to something, the first line especially “This is no case of petty right or wrong” seems to assert an answer. Even the word “petty” sounds assertive and harsh, both the sound and meaning give it a harsh and scornful feel. This poem could perhaps be a response to the likes of Jessie Pope and her poem “Who’s for the Game?” and various other jingoist writers of the time. This poem contrasts from Thomas’ other war poetry “The Sun used to Shine” and “As the Team’s Head Brass” as it
Open Document