'the Separation of Powers in a Presidential Democracy Ensures Better Government Than Parliamentary Democracies' Fusion of Power.' Discuss.

1117 Words5 Pages
'The separation of powers in a presidential democracy ensures better government than parliamentary democracies' fusion of power.' Discuss. Presidential democracies possess a separation of powers in that the executive and the legislature exist independently and hence 'the government does not depend on a legislative majority to exist' (Clark, Golder and Golder, 2009). This is in contrast to the fusion of powers in parliamentary democracies, which is a government 'directly controlled by the legislature' (Clark et al, 2009) and hence dependent on a legislative majority in a way presidential democracies are not. The statement alludes to the 'mutual independence' and 'mutual dependence' (Stepan and Skach, 1993) that characterises presidential democracy and parliamentary democracy respectively to suggest the former creates better government. While this essay does acknowledge that there are merits to the separation of powers in a presidential democracy, parliamentary democracies are capable of providing good government as well. As such, this essay argues that both forms of democracies have different merits and no system should be characterised as more capable of ensuring better government, given that we can adapt each system to compensate for apparent harms or create benefits to tailor each system to the different needs according to the political, economic and social conditions of each country. At first glance, presidential democracies do indeed appear to ensure better government than parliamentary democracies in that they serve as better representatives of the people. This is manifested in two main ways. Firstly, the 'mutual independence' that characterises a presidential democracy enables 'individual legislators [to] act on the basis of their individual electoral nneds' (Cheibub and Limongi, 2002), creating greater congruence between legislation enacted and the

More about 'the Separation of Powers in a Presidential Democracy Ensures Better Government Than Parliamentary Democracies' Fusion of Power.' Discuss.

Open Document