The Orderville Murder

2049 Words9 Pages
In 1908 in the small town of Orderville, Utah a young woman named Mary Stevens went missing. She lived with her parents just outside of Orderville in the small community of Glendale. Once it was established that she was not with relatives and was, in fact, missing, a search for whereabouts was launched. Three days later he body was found, in the foothills to the mountains outside of town, in a washout covered with rocks. She had been shot in the back four times, the pools of her blood on the rocks covered with sand. Only a bit of her clothing remained uncovered to show where she had been buried. The police soon turned to a local boy named Alvin Heaton junior under suspicion of the crime. He was detained, questioned and eventually charged with the murder of Mary Stevens. He went to trial and was found guilty of her murder, sentenced to life in prison at hard labor. However, there is evidence that Alvin Heaton was not actually guilty of the murder of Alvin Stevens, and although he confessed to the murder, Alvin Heaton was unfairly tried and convicted. In this paper we will analyze the sheriff’s investigative tactics, the evidence for and against Alvin Heaton presented at trial, the bias of the jury and the early release Alvin Heaton was able to procure from prison. When Sheriff James A. Brown, sheriff of Kane County, Utah in 1908, began the investigation of the murder of Mary Stevens he did so after the body of the deceased young woman had been tracked and found by her brother. In his own witness statement during the trial Joseph Stevens said “…he tracked [Mary] over the hills and into what is known as Garden Hollow where it appears she was joined by the tracks of a man…” and then after following the joint tracks “…that after looking in this place sometime he noticed blood on the rocks…”. It was at this time that Joseph went back into town and had the Sheriff and

More about The Orderville Murder

Open Document