Terminally Ill Patients Death Talk By Margaret Somerville

1807 Words8 Pages
Euthanasia has loon been a very controversial issue for many in the medical field and in the government. Doctors and patients alike have debated its legalization due to their dissimilar religious practices and/or political ideas. These issues pro-longing the confirmation of euthanasia, for example, is the inability to provide suffering patients with efficient end-of-life care by alleviating pain and doing it cost effectively and to not obligate patients in critical condition to euthanasia instead of a different cure. While these problems are minor setbacks others feel that by allowing doctors the right to terminate a patient’s life would endanger their personal freedoms and would consequently create a situation where terminally ill patients…show more content…
Written by Margaret Somerville, a professor of law at the McGill Centre for Medicine, Law and Ethics states that euthanasia is a way to perceive death in “reductionist” light (xiii). While Margaret Somerville makes a valid argument, she manipulates factual evidence to support her beliefs as well as relying solely on conviction that pro-euthanasia supporters are on a “primary intention of killing people” (Somerville 25) thus misleading her audience. She incorrectly sites a Dutch government study in 1990 and 1995 to see who participates in euthanasia, she has multiple fallacies which weaken her argument dramatically and she overlooks several statistics of patients and doctors who want to legalize euthanasia – these points make Somerville’s argument unsound but also leaves the audience struggling to agree with her…show more content…
The legalization of euthanasia would create an escape for incurable patients as well as securing the doctors credibility. This would let patients who do not want to be a burden the ability to leave with a sound mind, and to not let their families see them suffer. For everyone to leave with a smile and to know that they left with out endangering them selves or anyone else. Euthanasia may be a frightening topic and be difficult to discuss without religious or moral interference, but it is a choice that must be made to secure the patients well being and the doctor’s

More about Terminally Ill Patients Death Talk By Margaret Somerville

Open Document