Sometimes Lies Need to Be Told in Order to Protect People, Is This View Point Justified or Is It Just an Excuse?

450 Words2 Pages
Sometimes lies need to be told in order to protect people, is this view point justified or is it just an excuse? I bet that when everyone was a student, the teacher will tell you not to lie. So basically, in the point of view of an educated human, the statement “Sometimes lies need to be told in order to protect people” is it just an excuse. As a Christian, I think that this statement is not justified, it is just an excuse. According to the Online Oxford Dictionary, the definition of “lie” is an intentionally false statement. The definition of “justified” is show or prove to be right or reasonable. The definition of “excuse” is trying to justify. According to Number the Stars, all characters told lies to “protect people” from war. The Danish helped the Jews escape from the Germans. Both parties had lied to the German soldiers which was not a great idea. I strongly disagree that lying in order to protect people is justified. The first reason that the statement “Sometimes lies need to be told in order to protect people” is it just an excuse. There is a point or an example that fully shows that is just an excuse is the “funeral” of Great Aunt Birte who didn’t exist. The Danish wanted to prevent the Jews being caught, so they lied to the German Soldiers who suspected them. They excused them by not telling the truth. If the Danish really wanted to protect the Jews, they should not be scared of the soldiers and not telling the truth. If a person really wants to protect one, they will tell the truth. If the protector doesn’t tell the truth, the ones who were protected will be lying the next time. So it shows that lying will not protect them for a long time. This is a cause and effect situation, if people lie to a person, majorly, they will lie again. In this case, I can see that lying to the soldiers are just an excuse for a moment, because they are just keeping the
Open Document