Shylock Essay

397 Words2 Pages
Justified Paragraph: There were many ways in which Shylock did not belong in the society he lived in. The treatment that he received by others in his community resulted in his desire for revenge against Antonio. According to Midgley, “…it is not of much importance that Shylock is a Jew…The important thing is that he is a Jew in a Gentile society, that all he is and all he holds dear is alien to the society in which he has to live.” Shylock is portrayed as an outsider, but his treatment by others forces him to act differently as the other Venetians would. Like for example, Shylock doesn’t lend money out without interest, unlike Antonio. “He is an alien, an outsider, tolerated but never accepted. His being a Jew is not important in itself: what is important is what being a Jew has done to his personality. He is a stranger, proud of his race and its traditions, strict in his religion, sober rather than miserly in his domestic life,” (Midgley, 280). Shylock’s treatment outside his Jewish community made him act the way he did. When the moment came up to get revenge on his Christian peers, he jumped on it. But it did end badly, and not in his favor. Shylock was justified in a fair trial, but not justified in taking another man’s life. According to Albert Bermel, “To someone who looks askance on the play, the lines in the “Hath not a Jew’s eyes” speech seek to justify Shylock’s hardly sane passion for revenge, to reek of a contemporary lawyer’s reminder to a jury that his murderous client suffered a dreadful upbringing. The lines provide a rationale- but no justification.” Taking another man’s life over money is just cruel. Shylock just wanted to take Antonio’s life for revenge against him for all the time he treated Shylock terribly. Just because he treated Shylock un-fairly doesn’t mean he should kill him. Shylock seeks revenge but we should not forget he tried to
Open Document