Sell Surplus School Buildings

437 Words2 Pages
Choose one letter or editorial from the set provided. First, summarize the argument presented. Then, analyze and evaluate the argument presented. Be sure to identify the premises and conclusion(s) in the letter/editorial. In your response, consider how well the writer argues his or her point, whether the premises of the argument are warranted (believable); and whether or not the writer has included all the relevant information. Is the reasoning valid—in other words, do the premises provide good grounds for accepting the conclusion? If the argument doesn’t hold water, how would you argue the same point? Reading from the article "Sell surplus school buildings" was really intresting. The overall article was about how multiple schools may be closed due to the vexing problem of declining students enrollments. How they solved the situation was that the school had to shift the students. Now the Sac City Unified schol district should sell unused propreties as surplus to developers for other approprate uses. The arguement that I see that's presented is that "with an overall 10 percent reduction in students, what do we do with schools is no longer able…show more content…
I would say the arguement was warranted. Some of the information that the writer had was " the larger question is what to do with the idled schools sites themselves? Even schools have been closed since 2011. Far, far more were closed in earlier year. This trend will continue." I thought this was a good arguement because the writer has the year and examples that it will still continue on that there will be more in the coming year. The reasoning was valid of the premises that the writer provided for the conclusion. If the argument doesn’t hold water, how I would argue the same point is that I would provide as much evidnces as possiable. Try to get all the names of the students that for this situation about helping the school out. Overall, I will have give hopes of

More about Sell Surplus School Buildings

Open Document