Rationality: The Best Way Forward?

588 Words3 Pages
Rationality: the best way forward? Keith Franklin Introduction. Rationalism is a decision making model used in public organizations to accomplish an objective. In policy analysis, rationalism consists of the following steps: 1. An issue reaches the policy agenda. 2. Various objectives are formulated, studied and analysed. 3. The best alternative/strategy are selected from amongst the objectives. 4. The outcomes are evaluated. Etzioni (1967) observed "rationalistic models are widely held conceptions about how decisions are and ought to be made. An actor becomes aware of a problem, posits a goal, carefully weighs alternative means, and chooses among them according to his estimate of their respective merit, with reference to the state of affairs he prefers." Criticisms. According to Smith and May (1980) the rationalistic approach has been widely criticised. These criticisms are summarized below: 1. "....too narrow. Neglects the range of political variables which limits the extent of choice available in the light of the power of relevant vested interests. 2. Idealist. "The model represents, perhaps, the planner’s dream but in the real world it is argued, ends are not that clear, decisions are not that neat and evaluation is not that systematic." 3. Biased. "Particularly in an organisational context the model is accused of favouring management and senior professions to the detriment of low ranking staff, clients and patients". 4. "[R]ationalistic models are seen as too rigid in drawing sharp distinctions between ends and means, values and decisions, and facts and values." 5. impractical and costly "Even with the aid of computer technology a review and evaluation of all possible answers to a problem in order to select the optimal solution is seldom plausible and the cost of the search may well exceed the savings achieved by the solution...." Herbert

More about Rationality: The Best Way Forward?

Open Document