Nature Vs Nurture Case Study

2212 Words9 Pages
Rashaunna Nelson November 30th, 2012 Juvenile Justice and Delinquency – Professor J. Roman A Paper on the Topic Nature v. Nurture The course Juvenile Justice and Delinquency has taught me a great deal of information. There are many at-risk (extremely vulnerable to negative consequences such as school failure, substance abuse, and early sexuality) (Siegel & Welsh, 2011, 3) youth, that yearn for a sense of direction and a helping hand. With a plethora of research collected, studies from The United States Department of Justice show that “as many as 100,000 children are currently involved in prostitution, child pornography, and trafficking, but the true number may be in the millions” (Siegel & Welsh, 2011, xiii). Linda M. Williams…show more content…
Aaliyah struggled with family issues in California, and moved to Colorado with no plan in mind, and no place to stay. She turned to the streets for support, and she made it her home, and eventually found it comforting as she used drugs daily to make it through her stressful day on the streets (We will automatically assume that Aaliyah never partook in illegal activities, such as daily drug use). At the age of seventeen, she was arrested and detained for possession of drugs, and giving an officer false information. Aaliyah was standing at five feet seven inches, and only weighed 95 pounds. Luckily for Aaliyah, due to various variables, the court ordered for her case worker to make arrangements to get her back to her family in California. Aaliyah showed a desire to want to turn her life around, so her case worker became an advocate to get her the treatment she needed. Though the cost of treatment was tremendously expensive ($3000 per month to be exact) her case worker fought for her, and the department agreed to pay for her treatment up until the age of eighteen. “Although she has struggled with her sobriety on occasion, she has been able to refrain from using methamphetamines and is now at a healthy weight” (Siegel & Welsh, 2011, 2). Aaliyah’s story speaks on how her environment changed her personality, aiding to the idea of the nurture theory. “Nurture theorists discredit…show more content…
Just as in Aaliyah’s case profile story, there were many fostering variables to her delinquency. It began with her struggle at home with family issues. She felt hopeless living with her “mother, step-father and younger siblings” (Siegel & Welsh, 2011, 2). Next came her escape to Colorado, yet she had no game plan, which left her homeless, without support, and money. With no home, money, and support, she began to tamper with drugs that led to her arrest and detainment. Most important is the idea of youth. Like Aaliyah, and many other young teens around the world, “adolescence is a time of trial and uncertainty, a time when youth experience anxiety, humiliation, and mood swings” (Siegel & Welsh, 2011, 3). The years of youth become a stage of vulnerability for “external factors” (Siegel & Welsh, 2011, 3) as they mold themselves into individuals that are more likeable to their peers and colleagues. According to research from Linda Williams and Mary Frederick, “Many [youth] grew up in impoverished households where it was common for them to have encountered physical, sexual, and emotional abuse. Not only were they abused, but so too were there siblings, and many report having to protect younger brothers and sisters from abuse” (Siegel & Welsh, 2011, xiii). There are many cases such as these that are heartbreaking yet helpful. Cases such as Aaliyah’s, or research gathered, help guide
Open Document