'Montana 1948' by Larry Watson

737 Words3 Pages
In the novel Montana 1948 by Larry Watson the Hayden family are living harmoniously in Montana. David is twelve at the time when his uncle Frank Hayden is found guilty by the family of molesting Indian women and murdering Marie Little Solider, David’s babysitter. As the story unravels and David uncovers the truth, Wes, Julian, David and Frank all have different opinions on whether justice is more important than family, which is a constant struggle throughout the novel. Wes is torn between which is more important. Julian believes family is more important, while David sides with Justice. Wes struggles to decide between justice and family, which can clearly be seen throughout the novel. Though Wes knew his brother Frank was capable of the crimes, he didn’t want him to go to jail and refused to admit that the events which had unfolded were true. Wes carried out investigations hoping to find evidence proving that his brother wasn’t guilty. An example was when David saw his father Wes at the Coffee Cup. “With him sat Ollie Young Bear” who he was asking “if he had heard anything about Uncle Frank molesting Indian Women.” From the investigations Wes uncovered more and more evidence against Frank. Wes couldn’t decide whether to take Frank to Jail to receive his consequences or let the matter go. In the meantime Wes locked Frank in the basement to stop attracting attention from the public which bought some time for the family to make their decision. “This isn’t about family, this is a legal mater.” Wes said. “Bullshit. Then why have you got him locked up in here and not over at the jail?” Julian questioned. This is a prime example of Wes avoiding justice but not siding with family. Julian showed family to be more important than justice. This is displayed when Julian doesn’t think Frank should go to jail over an Indian. Two racist examples Julian said were “Screwing an
Open Document