Leadership in Education: a Comparison of Quantitative and Qualitative Research

3722 Words15 Pages
Qualitative and Quantitative Research The initial step of this research project is to locate three qualitative dissertations and three quantitative dissertations. The following is an analysis and summary of the contents and quality of each through the guide of a checklist for dissertations as provided in class. Corkill (1994) The first quantitative dissertation, which is by Corkill (1994), considered the instructional leadership behaviors in principals, which may contribute to academic achievement in elementary schools, as perceived by teachers and principals. Chapter 1 introduces instructional leadership as having the ability to change. The background of the problem is the ability of leadership to influence and understand teacher’s instructional concerns. Corkill states the problem as the need for principals to become more effective and improve in their role as an instructional leader. The research questions and purpose of the study were clearly identified. Corkill posed three research questions: 1. What is the relationship between the principals’ instructional leadership behaviors in selected South Texas elementary schools scoring above or below the State’s TAS average as perceived by their teachers? 2. What effect do the principal’s instructional leadership behaviors have on elementary schools scoring above or below the State’s TAAS in selected South Texas schools as perceived by their teachers? 3. Is there a difference in perceptions of principals and teachers on the effects of the principals’ instructional leadership behaviors on elementary schools coring above or below the State’s TAAS average in selected South Texas schools? Are we finding a positive effect of leadership on student achievement? The accountability of local school districts is strengthened using academic excellence indicators as well as providing data for professional development. The
Open Document