Journey's End Presents a Greater Sense of Loss That My Boy Jack, How Far Do You Agree?

1517 Words7 Pages
How far would you agree that Journey's End presents a greater sense of loss that My Boy Jack? Despite the plays being written in different times with different focus points, both Journey's End and My Boy Jack present heavy-hearted stories which portray a great sense of loss. Journey's End was a play written by R.C. Sheriff in 1928, 10 years after the war had started, that illustrated grievous emotions when two of the protagonists (Osbourne and Raleigh) die, leaving the audience feeling woeful with a deep sense of grief. Similarly in Haig's My Boy Jack, which was produced in 1997, displays a sense of loss from Rudyard Kipling and the rest of the family when they become aware of the death of their son Jack Arguably, My Boy Jack is much more distressing seeing as it is based on real life characters and around Rudyard Kipling's poem My Boy Jack unlike Journey's End being based on R.C. Sheriff's own experience of the war. The audience therefore feels they can get more attached to a true story, making it hit them harder emotionally. We see the impact of Jack's death mainly through his family, allowing the audience to experience a similar sort of pain due to the majority of them have lost someone close, being able to relate the Kipling family's pain. Jack's mother, Caroline, demonstrates such grief through her dialogue, 'I can feel his head on my chest...I can hear him laugh. I can feel his heat against me', remembering the memories she had with him and the repetitiveness suggesting she is having troubles coming to terms with this loss. Haig has used the present tense in the dialogue while talking about past actions in insinuate that Jack's mother is constantly reliving her life with her son and that she will never get over his death, connoting that she feels a very deep sense of loss and the audience can't help feel sympathy for her emotions. Comparatively, in Journey's
Open Document