Island Of Plenty Analysis

455 Words2 Pages
Montgomery’s essay Island Of Plenty uses the biblical reference of the Garden of Eden as a contrast to the current world. He also uses a great deal of logic to feed off the common fears of the common person, which develops his arguments about how the U.S. should not share resources with the countries in need. The Garden of Eden, a beautiful self-sustaining world with no fear and no pollution just a utopia printed and fantasized about in the early testament. Montgomery strengthens his argument about the problems of over population by using the biblical garden as a use of imagery. After his harsh opening paragraph on how the world should let those who starve die, he brings up the image of Eden and how perfect it was before man took control…show more content…
He talks about how resources are limited and the more people there are in this world, the more the competion there will be. His conclusion is that the United States, by aiding povish countries, are just barely keeping them alive enough to reproduce more that results in more people living a miserable existence. Those who can not provide should not reproduce which will result in the death of the excess people that eventually leads to equilibrium because their will be more to offer. Montgomery also peeks some interest in his morbid, yet sadly logical theory, by bringing to the attention of his readers how it will improve the economy. The over population problem also correlates with unemployment. Too many people need jobs hence the intense competition, which goes back to those in poverty because there are not enough jobs to employ all those who walk on earth. Montgomery is extremely crafty in his argument on Island of Plenty. He is able to twist his ugly determination on how to save the world by using logic and biblical imagery to understanding and actually, for most, agreeing with his ideas. He fights off most counter arguments that may confront him and all of his sentences are simple and to the point which creates a strong, comprehensible
Open Document