Integrity Essay

464 Words2 Pages
1. Choose two of the dilemmas and describe the decision that you would make in this situation and explain why. a.)Answer: The first dilemma that I would choose is the lifeboat dilemma. In this situation we have thirty survivors and only seven people can fit on the lifeboat. The dilemma I’m faced with is do I remove people off the lifeboat so that we all don’t die? Let’s stop right here! Nobody would be dying on my watch, and what I would do is if only seven could fit on the lifeboat at one time then we would have people get off the boat and hang on to the sides of the boat. We would switch off until helped arrived, because I don’t believe in giving up to the point I’m willing to sacrifice other’s lives to save my own or others. b.) Answer: The second dilemma that I choose is the dilemma about the psychologist that has a patient that believes her husband has threaten to kill her. He is already physically abusing her, and the threat seems very real to her. She has expressed to me that she plans to kill him before he kills her. One of the rules of having a license in my profession is protecting my patient’s privacy and my license could be revoked if I compromise this rule. Based on the fact that lives are in danger, I would be obligated to report this to the authorities. At this point I wouldn’t care about my career and what would happen to me, but for human life to be preserved is my only objective in this dilemma. 2. Review your answers and consider if you used the same values or if you used different values. How did your values relate to one another? Answer: I believe in both dilemmas I used the same values towards human life. In both dilemmas that I chose it dealt with human life and my choices made could have either saved life or possibly helped destroy life. That’s how both values applied relate to
Open Document