Incarcerating Adolescents

897 Words4 Pages
8 Editor’s Commentary A regressive step: Incarcerating adolescents with adults By Gregory K. Fritz, MD. hode Island has finally joined the movement already embraced by many states to incarcerate teenagers in our adult prison. Several months ago, in what was clearly defined as a costs-saving measure the face of a tight budget, the state legislature voted to move 17-year-olds from the Rhode Island Training School to the adult prison. Nationally, this trend began in the 1980’s as a way to “get tough on juvenile crime” in response to rising crime rates. Since 1992 most states have enacted policies that make it easier to prosecute and incarcerate teenagers in the adult criminal justice system, thus reversing the pattern of the previous 100…show more content…
“Protecting” teenagers by putting them in maximum security, as has been proposed, is not the answer. This level of sensory and social deprivation, physical inactivity and isolation is usually reserved for incorrigible, hardened prisoners. Such a sentence will have pervasive damaging effects. In addition, staff members in a juvenile facility and adult prison are not interchangeable in their skills sets. Staff members who work with teens need to a) understand the developmental tasks of adolescence, b) basically enjoy interactions with the age group, and c) have significant special training to be effective. Youth are more likely to reoffend when they are tried and incarcerated in the adult criminal justice system. Two…show more content…
Adolescents in such institutions compared to those in juvenile detention, are five times more likely to be sexually assaulted, eight times more likely to commit suicide, twice as likely to be beaten by staff, and 50% more likely to be attacked with a weapon. well-executed studies (one in New York/New Jersey, the other in Florida) compared recidivism rates of adolescents with comparable offenses who went through the juvenile versus adult systems. Both found that recidivism rates were higher and rearrests occurred more quickly for youth handled in the adult system. There is an ironic twist to Rhode Island’s legislation: the sole rationale for the decision was to save money. While incarceration in the Rhode Island Training School costs $98,000 per inmate per year, compared to an average of $39,000 in the Adult Correctional Institute, the protective custody in maximum security is reported to cost $100,552 per inmate per year. So much for cost savings. The ultimate absurdity is that our new, $73-million-dollar juvenile detention facility is scheduled to open at the end of this year. Rhode Island will be in the ludicrous position of having a state-ofthe-art facility (designed for a full secondary education program, fine pediatric medical and mental health services and vocational rehabilitation) sit under-used, while high-school-aged youth are locked in more expensive adult maximum security cells. Of course, as I mentioned above, Rhode Island

More about Incarcerating Adolescents

Open Document