“in What Ways May Disagreement Aid the Pursuit of Knowledge in the Natural and Human Sciences?”

1320 Words6 Pages
“In what ways may disagreement aid the pursuit of knowledge in the natural and human sciences?” Humans have a constant thirst of gaining knowledge to discover new ideas or concepts. The pursuit of knowledge has generally led to a more civilized and developed world. But sometimes, when people acquire knowledge, it clashes with their personal beliefs which lead to disagreement. Disagreement can be defined as having contradicting ideas in the society, which consists of scientists, researchers, students and many more. But, to what extent are logic and reasoning used to explain beliefs? Logic and reasoning is one way of acquiring knowledge; other ways of knowing are sensory perception, language and emotions. Knowledge is justified true belief backed by scientific evidence while belief is baseless usually rooted in religion, culture, or personal experience. In natural and human sciences, knowledge is gained by using the scientific method, falsifying an existing theory; however the knowledge obtained may collide with the personal beliefs of a researcher. Sometimes, arguments are a constructive way of acquiring knowledge particularly those which are based on logic and facts. While several people generally believe that a disagreement hinders the process of obtaining knowledge, this may not be the case as disagreement is a tool itself, of acquiring knowledge. It opens up room for development and further investigation. For example, in chemistry; an area in natural science, when Priestly and Lavoisier were developing the theory of elements, both of them acquired the same findings from the experiment. Both the researchers used the scientific method to conduct the experiment. Lavoisier used inductive reasoning, as he used the findings of this experiment to come up with the law of conservation of mass (“Lavoisier”). However, the problem with inductive reasoning is that it’s not

More about “in What Ways May Disagreement Aid the Pursuit of Knowledge in the Natural and Human Sciences?”

Open Document