Hunger Of Memory Analysis

1911 Words8 Pages
English 2 07 May 2013 False Impressions In the autobiography Hunger Of Memory, written by Richard Rodriguez the book recounts his personal experience of his education starting in childhood all the way to adulthood. Although Rodriguez has had much success as a student and as a writer, he always felt misplaced among is peers. Rodriguez argues to be successful students in the classroom that they need to sever their familial and cultural ties, especially if their home lives are very different from what they experience at school. Additionally, Rodriguez claims that our standards of beauty often determine our sense of worth in society. In reading the book I found fallacies that Rodriguez had in his writings, which included…show more content…
He felt that they were uneducated therefore they had undesirable jobs and people treated them differently because of it. Rodriguez notes, “I was not proud of my mother and father. I was embarrassed by their lack of education” (55). Rodriguez goes on to say, “Simply, what mattered to me was that they were not like my teachers” (55). In the book Rodriguez takes every thing that his teachers say at face value and he never questions if perhaps they could be wrong or mistaken on subjects. In school Rodriguez read acclaimed literary books: Great Expectations, Crime and Punishment, The Scarlet Letter, and Wuthering Heights. Which his teachers praised him for considering the books were a bit advanced for his grade and for the fact that other students lacked the ambition to read them. So he decides to be really ambitious and he wants to impress his teacher with his new reading choice. So he decides and tells his teacher that he wants to read the bible but the teacher (nun) feels that it is out of his reading comprehension and would be difficult for him to understand. Instead of challenging the nun he simply accepts what she says and does not read the bible. It shows that Rodriguez commits the fallacy of appealing to authority. The fallacy Appealing to Authority can be dangerous if a person never…show more content…
Rodriguez’s mother and aunts would use Spanish terms to describe skin tone. His aunts used to refer to their dark skin babies as, “mi feito” (my little ugly one) in Spanish (125). Rodriguez’s mother always worried about him doing anything in the sun because of how dark he would get and she would say she did not want him to look like a “bracero” (Mexican farm worker). Rodriguez goes on to write, “Dark skin was for my mother the most important symbol of a life of oppressive labor and poverty” (127). Through these experiences with his mother and aunt’s, Rodriguez starts to believe that his skin tone makes him ugly and unworthy. These feelings show that he believed the fallacy Appeal to Authority. Believing that since they were adults and knew the views of the world that they couldn’t be wrong in their statements. In addition Rodriguez had been a victim of racism while walking with friends. Rodriguez writes, a boy pedaled by and announced matter-of –factly, “I pee on dirty Mexicans” (125). He even saw other kids as authority because they were white and so he eventually had developed poor self-esteem from all the negativity of having dark skin. Rodriguez was also envious of his brother. Rodriguez continues,” And during those years I envied him his skin that burned red and peeled like the skin of the gringos” (123). He thought the girls his brother brought
Open Document