Harrison Bergeron vs. the Lottery

1184 Words5 Pages
Melissa Sanchez
2/7/2013
Daniel Hals English 2
Harrison Bergeron vs. The Lottery
“The Lottery” written by Shirley Jackson in 1948 and “Harrison Bergeron” written by Kurt Vonnegut in 1961 are both tragic stories about how society tends to conform to certain traditions or ways of being, no matter how gruesome, irrational or ridiculous. Society conforms to such bizarre traditions such as “stoning people to death” like in “The Lottery” from fear of what may happen to them if they do not comply.
Whether it is some spiritual, religious or physical punishment, everyone is scared of something and this fear brings out the worst in people. These stories are similar in many ways but they also have many differences; “The Lottery” seems to take place in an older New England village in 1948 when the people were a bit more barbaric than they are now whereas “Harrison Bergeron” takes place in the future, in the year 2081 somewhere in middle-America. In both stories, the main character, or what seems to be the main character, gets punished for questioning or defying the way of life in their hometown and both die while a family member(s) watch them.
In both “The Lottery” and “Harrison Bergeron”, the societies the people live in may seem barbaric, but in reality, they really do not differ much from today’s societies being that everyone seems to be fighting for equality. After reading these two stories, it makes me wonder; do people really want equality? At what cost will we gain this equality?
In Shirley Jackson’s “The Lottery”, the people live in a small village in New England and every year, a lottery is hosted with the entire village’s people gathered in one area which is only about 300 people. The night before the lottery, everyone’s name is put on a list so that they can be called the next day to choose a slip of paper from the black box. Once everyone has drawn, the
Open Document