Driving Ethical Dilemmas

1106 Words5 Pages
Ethical Dilemma Everyday more people will operate a motor vehicle and drive senseless by being under the influence of alcohol or drugs. Driving under the influence or driving while intoxicated is operating a motor vehicle with blood levels of alcohol or drugs that excess of the state legal limit. When a person is under the influence he or she can put other drivers and oneself in danger that can lead to death or injuries. Usually, the offender is too impaired to think about the consequence on what can happen for any unforeseen incident. In some countries it is a criminal offense. Blood alcohol content is measured by a threshold level of the state legal limit of 0.08%, however in some jurisdiction blood alcohol content can vary on the…show more content…
Gary Hosey, attempted to act in a good way by rushing home to return the vehicle to his girlfriend, so she can make it too work on time, although, his actions by speeding caused him to be in a crash. The girlfriend knew the offender did not have a driver license and she is wrong for allowing the offender to drive the vehicle. Gary showed some remorse at the first hearing and realizes that he committed a wrongful act. The Justice system gave Gary Hosey a higher bail amount compared to Justin Caramanica who committed the same offense. The ethical decision in this situation is based on utilitarianism. Justin Caramanica is placed on house arrest with an alcohol sensor bracelet with no driving privileges however he is waiting for sentencing in November, 2012. The ethical decision in this situation is based on deontological. Justin had a duty to perform certain actions and he failed to do so; he knew the judge directive order was violated. The justice system made a ethical bias decision base on race and prior criminal history…show more content…
On September 24, 2012, Justin was arrested for another driving under influence (DUI), driving without proof of insurance and driving with suspended licenses. Justin bail has been revoked on the result of the second driving under influence (DUI). Gary Hosey bail is at an enomorsously higher amount that his family is unable to afford. Each offender is waiting for a hearing in November, 2012.
Open Document