Do You Agree with the View That in the Years 1515-25 Henry Viii Wholly Surrendered Power in Government to Cardinal Wolsey?

892 Words4 Pages
Do you agree with the view that in the years 1515-25 Henry VIII wholly surrendered power in government to Cardinal Wolsey? Explain your answer, using Sources 4, 5 and 6 and your own knowledge. It is hotly debated whether or not Henry VIII wholly surrendered power in government to Cardinal Wolsey. To analyse the extent of the truth of this statement we must consider the views of others, both at the time of the events and modern historians, source 4, a book from J.J Scarisbrick reviewing the relationship of the King and Wolsey another book (source 5) by John Lotherington also reviewing Wolsey and the King’s relationship and a letter (source 6) written by Henry VIII himself which perfectly demonstrates their relationship. All of which have differing opinions, but overall the ultimate power lay with Henry. Source 4 agrees with the statement stating that the king “had wholly surrendered the cases of state to the Cardinal’s hand” directly agreeing with the statement and showing that Henry gave all power to Wolsey so as “to cast off the cares” this is supported by Source 6 where Henry dismissively tells Wolsey to “keep a careful watch on… others of whom you are suspicious” this clearly illustrates that Henry VIII would offload matters of state into Wolsey’s hands and allow him to respond as he wished showing a clear passing of the reins of power. However when analysing these sources it is important to consider the nature origin and purpose of the source. Source 4 is quoting a servant of Wolsey George Cavendish who was not privy to Wolsey’s political power or action but was merely a personal companion and thus would wish to create a grand image for his employer and exaggerate his strength this significantly limits the reliability of the source. Yet Source 6 is directly from Henry VIII and thus flawlessly demonstrates the king’s opinion regarding the power of Wolsey
Open Document