Diversion Programs Research Paper

2319 Words10 Pages
Diversion Programs: An Overview The Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice The Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice (CJCJ) is a private nonprofit organization whose mission is to reduce society's reliance on incarceration as a solution to social problems. CJCJ provides programs to persons facing prison, educates the public about the effects of imprisonment, and provides technical assistance to jurisdictions wishing to establish model programs for offender populations. CJCJ maintains a staff of professionals with diverse backgrounds and expertise in various components of the criminal and juvenile justice field. As part of its commitment to reform, CJCJ incorporates exoffenders on its board and staff. CJCJ, which has offices in San Francisco,…show more content…
Gibbons and Krohn (1991:313) observed, "For one thing, the recommendation that community services be coordinated by the bureau assumed that there was a wealth of services to be coordinated when, in fact, the lack of such agencies and services had been an impediment to successful juvenile court work." It should not be surprising, therefore, that conflicting expectations, findings, and conclusions would emerge from such a widespread, disjointed, and complicated social experiment. Although many studies show that diversion programs are successful in reducing subsequent deviance, these studies are balanced by studies that find no impact. In certain cases, diversion programs were found to have detrimental properties (Polk, 1995). Research Proponents of diversion, however, cite studies such as one in Colorado that involved comparisons between an experimental group of diverted youth and a control group who received regular handling by the juvenile justice system. The diversion program administered individual, parental, and/or family counseling to the diverted youth group, resulting in significantly lower recidivism rates than in the control group (Pogrebin, Poole, and Regoli, 1984; see also Frazier and Cochran, 1986; Gilbert, 1977). A large-scale diversion program in Michigan, the Adolescent Diversion Project (Davidson et al., 1990), included juveniles accused of serious criminal acts and juveniles with status offenses. The study concluded that diversion can be safely extended beyond status and minor offenders. Although most of the offenders in the program admitted to criminal acts, the diversion programs reported lower recidivism rates than those reported for normal court-processed cases. The most successful diversion programs have been those that provide more intensive and comprehensive services (Dryfoos, 1990). The use of experienced youth caseworkers is especially important to a program's success. For

More about Diversion Programs Research Paper

Open Document