Critical Issues In Criminal Justice: Domestic Violence Cases

1062 Words5 Pages
Intimate Partner Violence Darryl Jackson CCJ 5450 Critical Issues in Criminal Justice Dr. Ken Mullen August 3, 2013 Domestic violence is serious problem that our police forces all across the nation are forced to deal with on a daily basis. There is no quick fix or magic answers to solve this problem. I have seen cases of domestic violence that are quite sickening. The police are not quite sure how to handle it because policies and laws in reference to partner violence are ever changing. The police get frustrated with these calls because there are times when they get a call and they see the address and realize that it one that they have to respond to on a weekly basis. They arrive at the scene only to find that the victim does not…show more content…
The cases that were used in the study were misdemeanor assault calls, which is the majority of domestic violence calls. The victim and offender needed to still be present when the police arrived on the scene. The study included 51 officers from the Minneapolis Police Department. Each officer was asked to use one of three approaches for handling domestic violence calls, in cases where officers had probable cause to believe an assault had occurred. They were 1.) send the abuser away for eight hours, 2.) advice and mediation of disputes and 3.) make an arrest. Interviews were conducted during a 6-month follow-up period, with victims and offenders, as well as official records consulted to determine whether or not re-offending had taken place. The study included 330 cases (Cole & Gertz,…show more content…
The study sites included police departments in Omaha, Nebraska, Charlotte, North Carolina, Milwaukee, Wisconsin, Miami, Dade County, Florida, and Colorado Springs, Colorado. The number of cases varied in each city. There was also a study initiated in Atlanta but it was never completed. The findings from the five completed replications were reported independently in 1990. The findings about crime control effects of arrest varied depending upon the site studied, the measures of repeat offending used, and alternative treatments compared to arrest. Each replication reported multiple findings with some results favoring arrest, some showing no differences and some showing that arrest was associated with more repeat offending. None of the replications reported effects as strong as those reported for the Minneapolis Experiment. According to Cole and Gertz, there were two articles synthesizing the findings from these studies report a crime control effect for the use of arrest for domestic violence. A meta-analysis of the published findings based on official police records from the Minneapolis and the SARP experiments reported a deterrence effect for arrest (“Cole & Gertz”,

More about Critical Issues In Criminal Justice: Domestic Violence Cases

Open Document