Comparison Between Hamlet Films

1209 Words5 Pages
A comparison of the two films There are many differences in both depictions of the original play be Shakespeare, in Kenneth Branagh’s Hamlet, starring Branagh himself as Prince Hamlet, Julie Christie, Kate Winslet, Brian Blessed, and Derek Jacobi, among others was released on December 25, 1996. Branagh’s version as a whole captures the essential elements, themes, and dramatizations of the centuries old play. His vision is quite clear, and he brings debated interpretations to the surface. While there is a modern spin on the story—it’s setting being sometime in the 19th century, it still remains true to the characters’ many dimensions and struggles, and reveals hidden secrets—demonism, sex before marriage, and complex madness. On the other hand, Franco Zeffirelli’s Hamlet, starring Mel Gibson, Glenn Close, Alan Bates, Paul Scofield, Helena Bonham-Carter, Jan Holm, and released in 1990, takes a more dramatic, hidden approach to the story. While Zeffirelli is true to the plotline, his personal interpretation of the film is not as refined as Branagh’s. In fact, it is similar to the play in the sense that the entire story appears to be left open to discussion. The strength of the film lies in the portrayal of the time period—costumes, cinematography, etc, and in the displeasure of the characters, which is brought on by the actors. While both films depict the complicated structure of the play with accuracy, Branagh makes his analysis clear and defined, while Zeffirelli seems to rely on the story and hides the issues of the play, making his personal interpretation less obvious. In both films many aspects of the story are portrayed differently. One aspect was the theory of the ghost .In Branagh’s film, when Hamlet discovers through Horatio, Marcellus and Bernado that his father’s ghost has revealed himself, he quotes the lines from the play, “My father’s spirit in arms!
Open Document