Comparative Essay (2 Short Stories)

434 Words2 Pages
Comparative Essay By: Shola Eubanks Oct. 2, 2012 Two stories that can be compared to each other are “The Bicycle” by Jillian Horton and “Father is Firm” by Clarence Day. Both writers used similar techniques to create the story, for example they both used suspense. They have created two completely different stories with similar characters. Firstly, the themes are different but somehow the same. The theme for the story “The Bicycle” is choosing between what people want for you and what you want for you. Choosing between what people want you to do and what you want to do or believe in. The protagonist, Hannah was being taught to play piano professionally by her aunt and has been doing so from when she was young. In the story Hannah's aunt Tante Rose (antagonist), is getting in her way of fitting in with her friends and riding a bike. Tante Rose restricts Hannah from riding a bike because of her bike accident. Which makes her close-minded to the idea of riding the bike. Tante Rose is close-minded and stubborn just like the main character in the story “Father is Firm”. In this story, the main character, Clarence Day is close-minded to the idea of taking medicine or orders from a doctor to defeat an illness. The theme of this story is trying to overcome a sickness or illness on your own is not very wise. In the story, Clare's wife Vinnie Day was catching a fever and didn't know how to deal with it because of his close-mindedness towards sicknesses. Secondly, the familial relationships. In “The Bicycle”, the relationship between Hannah and Tante Rose isn't far but one could say that it isn't close. They were once very close as the story says, but started to grow apart once Hannah started growing up. The rules of becoming a pianist and their practice schedules were preventing Hannah from doing what she wanted to do most, which was riding a bike. “The Bicycle” is
Open Document