Community For Creative Non-Violence (CCNV)

1159 Words5 Pages
Business Law Case Analysis The case was between Community for Creative Non-Violence (CCNV), a nonprofit institution that was fighting for the right to solve the problem for the homelessness, and James Earl Reid, a sculptor. The community for Creative Non-Violence (CCNV) was the plaintiff while Reid was the defendant. CCNV was an institution situated in Washington; D.C that was known for its reputation for fighting for the homelessness. Reid, on the other hand, was a sculptor and was working on the statute that had been ordered by the CCNV. The two had entered in to an oral agreement that Reid would produce a statute depicting homeless people, according to their agreement; Reid was to set up words on the sculpture that that dramatizes the plight of the homelessness. The statute was set to be displayed at the 1985 Christmas pageant in Washington. The company could check on Reid occasionally to make sure that the work was in progress, and that the construction of the sculpture base was in accordance with the stated agreements. Reid worked according to the CCNV’s suggestions and instructions until the whole structure came to completion. After completion, the sculpture…show more content…
The judgment was based on the ground that the statute was in this case made for hire, and as defined by the copyright act by that time, the sculpture ownership exclusively went to CCNV. The copy right act stated that, ownership for any work of hire should go to the employer, unless the two involved parties present a written agreement to the contrary. However, the court of appeal, later on, reversed the hearing, holding that the sculpture was not made for hire as had been stated before. The court stated that Reid was in independent contractor and not an employee within the scale of the employment, therefore, the first set of conditions used to make the ruling were not

More about Community For Creative Non-Violence (CCNV)

Open Document