‘Comedy Involves Men of Middling Estate; Its Perils Are Small Scale, Its Outcomes Peaceful’. to What Extent Do You Agree with This Definition of Comedy in Relation to Much Ado About Nothing?

2693 Words11 Pages
‘Comedy involves men of middling estate; its perils are small scale, its outcomes peaceful’. To what extent do you agree with this definition of comedy in relation to Much Ado about Nothing*? Shakespeare’s Much Ado about Nothing is one of the most popular comedies in history, selling out Shakespearean theatres until their closure in 1642. The comedy is thought to be written in 1598 and is often described as a ‘problem play’ meaning it shares tendencies with that of a tragedy. Of course MAAN follows Shakespeare’s traditional comedy structure but modern critics have their own agenda that a comedy, being such a complex genre, should conform to. Since the time of the ancient Greeks critics have struggled to define it, Plato described it as a series of events you would ‘blush to practice yourself’. Susan Snyder who writes for the Cambridge Companion to Shakespeare Company, states that - ‘Comedy involves men of middling estate, its perils are small scale, its outcomes peaceful’. This is an excellent summary for the majority of Shakespeare’s plays; however it is not necessarily accurate in relation to MAAN. It is true to say that a comedy involves ‘men of a middling estate’, in MAAN the protagonists share the company of the Prince Don Pedro, and are socially superior to the watchmen such as Dogberry and Verges. What Snyder is implying is that comedies centre very much on social hierarchy and formalities. The males in MAAN use language in order to demonstrate their position in society, in time of production courtiers were expected to speak in highly contrived language but to make their clever performances seems effortless; this is no more evident than of Benedick who constantly uses wit in order to prove his wisdom to the other characters. In his ‘merry-war’[1] with Beatrice he responds shrewdly and fast-paced, calling her - in response to one of her remarks - a

More about ‘Comedy Involves Men of Middling Estate; Its Perils Are Small Scale, Its Outcomes Peaceful’. to What Extent Do You Agree with This Definition of Comedy in Relation to Much Ado About Nothing?

Open Document