Catcher In The Rye Optimism Vs Reality Analysis

1099 Words5 Pages
Monet Jimenez Period 2 December 2, 2008 Optimism Vs. Reality Is Holden’s view of the world pessimistic but accurate, or is he completely detached from reality? The novel, Catcher In The Rye, by J.D. Salinger, the main character of this story, experiences bumps in his road of life, and the question as to whether the outlook on life from his perspective is simply pessimistic, or a complete detachment from reality. Throughout the story, it is never clearly stated that Holden is going through any emotional strain, but Holden performs odd, anxious behavior that are indefinitely prominent he is. It seems as if though God were out to get him, because nothing ever pans out to his advantage. Consecutive struggles fall onto…show more content…
Finally, Holden did not accept the reality of his brother's death, which was indicated during one of Holden's visits to Allie's grave. During the visit, it began to rain. All the other visitors ran for the protection of their cars, but Holden felt depressed because Allie could not escape the rain. When he saw the visitors leaving, Holden scowled at the thought of them going some place fore dinner, while Allie could only lie in his grave. Holden continued to believe that his brother felt emotions. He repeatedly gave Allie the characteristics of a living being, proving that he never fully accepted Allie's death. Obviously, Holden's many unusual thoughts regarding death signified that Holden needed mental help. Holden's communication problems also displayed his need to live in a mental institution. For example, on the train to New York City, Holden conversed with Mrs. Morrow. Holden spoke with the woman because he desperately sought attention and felt the need to communicate with someone. He chose to communicate with Mrs. Morrow because he

More about Catcher In The Rye Optimism Vs Reality Analysis

Open Document