Bartleby vs a Sorrowful Woman

1167 Words5 Pages
Craig Bandy AP English, 1b 01-11-13 Bartleby VS. A Sorrowful Woman Bartleby, the Scrivener, and A Sorrowful Woman reflect each other in a lot of ways. They have very similar themes and plots. The main theme from both stories is that untreated mental illness can lead to death, as we see at the end of both short stories. Both stories start with an epigraph. In a sorrowful woman is says “once upon a time there was a wife and mother one too many times” (Godwin 33). This shows how the woman feels towards her husband and child, and shows that the story will not be happy. Next Bartleby’s epigraph states “A story of Wall Street” (Melville 91). Which as the reader sees throughout the story is symbolic of the setting of the office. Both Bartleby and woman suffer from mental conditions that deteriorate over time, both mentally and physically. The stories both include an outside character that attempts to help, but overall just enables the main character and allows him/her to keep deteriorating. Bartleby starts out as a man who is “pallidly neat, pitiably respectable, and incurably forlorn” (Melville 95) in other words he is a very dull character. He starts out as a very hard worker and doesn’t seem to lead a very interesting life. The sorrowful woman also starts out as a normal person living a dull life. Both characters seem to be able to carry on just fine at the beginning of the stories. The deterioration of Bartleby’s health can be seen as soon as he starts objecting to the lawyers requests. The line he uses is “I would prefer not to” (Melville 97). Although he is saying that he would prefer not to, in actuality he is telling the lawyer that he will not do what is asked of him. The lawyer allows Bartleby to get away with this, which leads to Bartleby’s demise. The lawyer enables Bartleby, so in a way, the lawyer killed Bartleby. “The sight of them made her so sad and
Open Document