Article Rebuttal

629 Words3 Pages
Article Rebuttal BCOM/275 September 15 2013 Article Rebuttal Genetically modified foods are a topic that I find very interesting, mostly because I chose not to eat them. As I would normally take a position against the safety of these types of foods, I thought it would be a challenge to take the pro position as a change. For this purpose I selected an article called, “Genetically Modified Food Wrapped.” The article was written by Dr. Thierry Vrain and published in the Vancouver Sun on April 29th of 2013. Dr. Vrain starts the article by stating his professional experience working as a research scientist for Agriculture Canada. Additionally he mentions that he has previously argued in support of the safety of genetically modified foods…show more content…
Vrein, “The Bt corn and soya plants that are now everywhere in our environment are registered as insecticides. But are these insecticidal plants regulated and have their proteins been tested for safety? Not by the federal departments in charge of food safety, not in Canada and not in the U.S.” However the United States Food and Drug Administration directly conflicts this statement with information directly on their website. Specifically they state the following, “Evaluating the safety of food from a genetically engineered plant is a comprehensive process that includes several steps. Generally, the developer identifies the distinguishing attributes of new genetic traits and assesses whether any new material that a person consumed in food made from the genetically engineered plants could be toxic or allergenic,” (FDA 2013) In these few sentences the FDA clearly and directly undercuts the entire argument set forth by Dr. Vrain. At this point it becomes clear that the author is stating opinion not fact, there are no sources cited with any specifics and therefore the author’s credibility has been significantly decreased. The author is using rhetorical devices to attempt to persuade the audience. Appeal to ignorance is his main form of persuasion. As he starts the article by stating he is a professional in the field, he is playing to an audience that does not have any opinion on the matter and using ignorance and fear as his devices. In summary without any sources

More about Article Rebuttal

Open Document