Adoption Controversy- Birth Records

1096 Words5 Pages
Adoption Controversy: Should Birth Records Be Open or Closed? Adoption is the legal process by which a person becomes a lawful member of a family different from their original birth family. Once a decree of adoption has been finalized by a court of law, the new adoptive parents gain the same rights and responsibilities as parents whose children are biologically birthed. Subsequently, an adopted child gains the same rights as birth children in regard to inheritance, child support, and other legal matters. In most U.S. jurisdictions, at the time the adoption is finalized, the adopted child's name is legally changed and the court orders the issuance of a new, amended birth certificate. This amended copy usually contains all of the information found in the original birth certificate except for the names of the birth mother and father. These names are simply replaced by the new adoptive parents names. Once an amended birth certificate is issued to the new parents, the original birth certificate and other adoption records, including records of court proceedings and agency reports and interview testimonies, are sealed to protect the confidentiality of everyone involved in the adoption. One voice that does not get heard when considering what is best for the child is that of the child itself. Adult adoptees should have unrestricted access to their original adoption records when they reach the legal age of eighteen. Currently the laws do not allow adopted people the right to access their original birth certificate or their original adoption decrees. Some consider this to be unfair treatment of citizens who have come into their perspective families through adoption. All biological children would be able to go to the Department of Health and pay a fee to receive a copy of their birth certificate. In addition, adult adoptees are not able to obtain a copy of their
Open Document