Trying on the Shoes in “the Caretaker” - a Comparative Commentary

579 Words3 Pages
One of the recurring themes in Harold Pinter's “The Caretaker” are the eponymous character's, shoes (or lack thereof). Aston offers shoes to Davies twice, in acts I and III, but he rejects both pairs. However, even though the subject and result of their conversations are the same, the scenes differ in many ways, showcasing the dramatic change that occurred in the characters' relationship. This change can be seen in the first lines of Aston and Davies's conversations. While in act I Aston gives Davies shoes with polite “Try these”, in the second scene Aston says only “Pair of shoes”, an incomplete sentence with no clear addressee. It is worth noting that this is the first conversation between them we get an account of after Aston's monologue by the end of act II. It was then that he shared with Davies some of his most intimate experiences (including his mental history), probably in hope of befriending him. However, it is clearly visible that his attempt failed and as a result Aston returned to being careful and laconic, even to the point of incomprehension. Davies's reactions to Aston's offers are also revealing of the change in their relations. In the first scene he tries the shoes on immediately. In the second one, however, he is reluctant to do so; Aston has to repeat his offer twice. The main reason for this might be the fact that now Davies knows about Aston's mental issues and considers himself superior to him. It is as if Davies assumed that the shoes ”nutty” Aston had brought are not worth his attention. Davies's now patronizing attitude towards Aston is also visible when he explains to him why he can not wear shoes without laces, constantly making sure if Aston understands him by asking “You see what I'm getting at?” and “See?” a couple of times. In both scenes shoes are ill-fitted. However, while in the first scene this fact was revealed after a
Open Document