Three of a Kind (Comparrisson Essay of Three Sherlock Holmes Adaptations)

855 Words4 Pages
Three of a Kind One of the greatest literary characters of all time is Sherlock Holmes. Known by many and also portrayed by many. According to Ronald Burt De Waal’s The Universal Sherlock Holmes, there have been over 25,000 different adaptations and productions of Sherlock Holmes. Conan Doyle first published Sherlock Holmes in 1887 and his character has stayed mostly the same over these past 125 years, but each portrayal has its own unique differences. After watching several versions, here are how a few compare to each other and the original Sherlock Holmes. The first portrayal of Sherlock that we saw was Benedict Cumberbatch’s in the BBC Series Sherlock. This is by far my favorite version of Sherlock that we have seen to date. He fits all of the characteristics that you would expect Holmes to have and portrays them in a modern feel. One of the big changes in the Sherlocks over the years is the appearance. Benedict Cumberbatch has a much more modern feel to his look, while keeping to the original feel of Sherlock. He wears a large coat most of the time and is always professionally dressed, aside from the episode when he decides that a sheet is the best attire for the day. They stay away from the old school hat, large over coat, and pipe that Sherlock always had in past decades. Sherlock has the science of deduction, and of course is still used as the big skill of Holmes, but in this modern BBC version, because of advancements in technology they can slow down scenes and it allows us to deduct with Sherlock. The changes in technology is the biggest difference in this version of Sherlock compared to older versions. For instance, instead of a telegram text messages play a big role in this series and just shows that communication was faster. One of the homoios’ of Sherlock is him being a drug addict, and in this newer version, they tone it down to just nicotine

More about Three of a Kind (Comparrisson Essay of Three Sherlock Holmes Adaptations)

Open Document