The Political Trial Of Anne Hutchinson

689 Words3 Pages
Anne Hutchinson V. Massachusetts The trial of Anne Hutchinson was a strange one to me, in that she seemed capable of winning her freedom, but chose to let her own self-image shine through. Anne Hutchinson, a 45-year-old woman, wife and mother to 13, going on 14 children, stands trial in front of the powerful John Winthrop. For some time, Anne Hutchinson had questioned the teachings, and the overall thought process of the puritan route to salvation. Puritans believed that you are either saved, or damned from birth. This means that there was nothing a person could do to save him or herself. No amount of prayer, or good doings could change the predetermination of the Holy Ghost. Anne Hutchinson spoke out, saying that the church was teaching not a covenant of “grace” but one of “works.” She goes even further, to say that they are incapable of preaching a covenant of grace. Anne was convinced that she, along with her beloved minister Cotton, and her brother in law were the only ones capable of correctly delivering the word of god. Anne had been holding meetings in her home, meeting that landed her in the position she finds herself in. She claimed at these meetings to be receiving her revelations from the Holy Ghost itself. As the trial first begins, Anne seems to have the upper hand over Winthrop. She manages to make him look foolish. She questions everything he says, and admits to nothing. Winthrop becomes angered, and turns the trial over to his deputy governor, Thomas Dudley. Dudley is a man more suited for the task at hand, as he isn’t afraid to do what needs to be done. Dudley then brought six ministers as witnesses to what Anne Hutchinson had been teaching at her secret meetings. These six ministers confirmed what Dudley and Winthrop failed to get out of Hutchinson, witch was the fact that she proposed only she, and Cotton could preach a covenant of grace.
Open Document