Sunflower Essay

585 Words3 Pages
Duncan Blackston April 25, 2011 The Sunflower Paper The Sunflower After reading the book, The Sunflower: On the Possibilities and Limits of Forgiveness,” Simon Wiesenthal tells of his experience while he was encamped as a prisoner. He sat down and spoke with a member of the SS who was dying in the hospital in an attempt to receive forgiveness so that he might die in peace. The book title outlines what the theme of the book is he reveals his encounters. Wiesenthal inquired of his roommates and readers what is “the possibilities and limits of forgiveness.” The sick man in the hospital seized Wiesenthal’s hand and confessed to helping destroy, by fire and armaments, a house filled with more than 150 Jews. When Karl Seidl finished his story, he begged the Jewish forced-laborer to forgive him. Wiesenthal, however, rose and walked out. During the next two years, Wiesenthal shared this story with fellow camp mates, ending each time with: “Was my silence at the bedside of the dying Nazi right or wrong?” The incident and question so troubled Wiesenthal that, in 1946, he visited Karl Seidl’s mother in Stuttgart but left without telling the bereaved woman about her son’s misdeeds. A number of essayists chose to respond to Wiesenthal’s question thusly: “What would I have done [in Simon Wiesenthal’s place]?” Although Wiesenthal acceded to such a “paraphrase,” this writer agrees with responder Lawrence Langer that such role-playing about Holocaust reality trivializes the serious issues of judgment and forgiveness that The Sunflower raises. Forgiveness is, indeed, the essence of the debate that high scholars should enter into. Nowhere is the dichotomy regarding the possibility of Wiesenthal’s forgiveness so great as it is between the Jewish and Christian scholars. Students could be exposed to the Christian rationale of, say, John Pawlikowski’s conception of repentance,
Open Document