Speeches; Migrant Hostel and 10 Mary Street

1055 Words5 Pages
Question: How do these TWO poems demonstrate the impact of place and people on an individual’s sense of belonging? Thesis: Belonging requires a sense of security in place and of people. Migrant Hostel -‘arrivals of newcomers, sudden departures’ –uncertainty, instability, lack of control. -‘nationalities sought each other out like a homing pigeon circling to get its bearings…’ –animal imagery, simile, metaphor for the migrants themselves who have travelled and are now lost in an unstable environment, away from home. ‘A barrier at the main gate rose and fell, pointing in reprimand or shame’ –Stability shown in that, but it is imposed, they are entrapped and isolated. 10 Mary Street -‘shut the house / like a well-oiled lock / Hid the key / under a rusty bucket’ –simile, juxtaposition security. Belonging there is easy –undermines their security, subtly imposes that belonging can be tenuous -‘Tended roses and camellias / like adopted children’ –simile, metaphor-the place was nurtured and worked hard on like family, part of their identity -‘We lived together / heated discussions, embracing gestures’ –strong sense of cultural belonging with people. Differs to Migrant ‘memories of hunger and hate. An individuals sense of belonging is formed through the security of bonds with people and place. In Skrzynecki’s poems he explores the factors that contribute to the connection of identity and culture through their sense of stability. ‘Migrant Hostel’ demonstrates how belonging cannot be imposed nor fostered in an unstable environment. Conversely, ‘10 Mary Street’ reflects that when a stable connection and care for place is formed independently, belonging is inevitable. Skrzynecki portrays persona’s that are influenced by his own experiences put in situations where the need to belong is challenged or embraced. Stability plays a

More about Speeches; Migrant Hostel and 10 Mary Street

Open Document