Argumentative Essay To: Mr. Dotzko From: Jean-Marc Francois Due Date: December, 19/11 Child spanking is a huge issue in our world today and some people consider it abusing each other while others say it’s fair discipline. These opposing opinions have been going on for a while according to our law system there’s a fine line between abuse and child spanking but a lot of people say it’s bad parenting to spank children and shouldn’t be done. Child spanking is a fair way to discipline your children and is not abusive according to the Human Right Code. It’s an effective way to discipline children and get them into shape but it can be considered abuse because it causes a lot of increased aggressiveness in children. Child abusing and child spanking are two completely different things and I think that it’s just fine to discipline your children with spanks and that it’s not abusive.
We have to show our limits and guide our children in positive behavior so that we can avoid spanking or any other form of corporate punishment. As to me, hitting or spanking our children is not the best way to influence them in being well behaved. They would behave better if we don’t spank them just punish them in other ways of talk to them. Article 2 Patti Bokony & Teri Patrick, Spanking: What the Experts Say ; TIPS 07-B1 Summary Spanking is a form of corporate punishment, as it may not be as harsh as punching, kicking or burning. It is still considered some form or child abuse.
The Negative Effects of Corporal Punishment on Children Have you ever heard someone say, “ I was spanked as a child, and nothing ever happened to me?” Parents often assume that their children will experience the same reaction to corporal punishment as they did, but there are many essential things that need to be taken into consideration before establishing a disciplinary technique for an individual child. The personality, mental and emotional state, and the genetic make-up of the child need to be acknowledged. Some children are more prone to acquiring life-long consequences due to corporal punishment than others. Corporal punishment will not make your child an angel if that’s what you were thinking; in fact, it can do just the opposite. Corporal punishment is a negative disciplinary technique to correct bad behavior and decisions those of children.
Turley argued that violent toys offer advantages because they aid children in channelling their aggression and seen as a valuable vehicle to process violence. However he failed to address how this could help convince zero-tolerance parents who viewed violent toys as an encouragement of aggressive behaviours and violent attitude. Despite putting in reasonable effort in his claim of having a healthy dose of violence, the result would as undesirable if violence had been misinterpreted or mishandled such as in the case of the 1999 Columbine High School shootings. Turley should therefore be educating parents on guiding their children when playing with such violent toys and not exposing to children directly. While Turley provides sufficient amount of evidence from various professionals, the essence of the author’s original argument that violent toys should be seen as beneficial was lost in the midst of quoting the many opinions and research of other individuals.
The majority of Americans will say that spanking is abusive, that it teaches children to be aggressive, and that there is no instructional value. These are all myths. Abusive parents do not use spankings for correctional purposes; they lash out and take their anger out on their children. Second, abusive parents don’t just spank they hit or beat their children. But for non abusive parents, spanking is done out of love and care to correct a child’s behavior.
You see many shows like Super Nanny were kids walk all over the parents, because they know that all they get is a time out. Parents have to deal with a lot from their kids that they shouldn't have to take over and over. Parents try and take things from their kids, but it turns out that the kids cause more problems because their bored without it. Kids do things that they shouldn't and parents tell them they can’t do that by giving them a light spank on the butt. The parents show that their not going to allow the child goofing off and they will be listened to.
Spank No More: The Ways to Effectively Discipline A Child Child corporal punishment is an extremely popular form of punishment in American families today. Corporal punishment is a form of punishment that involves the deliberate infliction of pain as retribution for an offense or for the purpose of disciplining. Most parents resort to spanking their children for bad behavior and some parents simply feel that a good hard spanking is necessary and mostly harmless. Although corporal punishment may seem to be the easiest way to discipline a misbehaving child, it is not the most effective. There are a few more effective ways of discipline children without having to resort to corporal punishment.
In that case, tough love becomes nearly meaningless. Rather than making the children feel uncomfortable you have to find the best parenting style of discipline. For some reason, the concept of tough love has been usually criticized as a parent’s excuse to bully their children, in that matter bullying teens could resolve in to using drugs. Some drug treatment programs use the words tough love to describe their approach on helping the children. But some people may take the meaning as cruel, but as a resolute of the program it is successful only by breaking down the motivation of the young person in treatment.
I. Many parents, who use corporal punishment for discipline, do not understand that they are abusing their child. A. According to Javed Kashni’s 1998 book Raising Happy Children, he states “A child who is spanked learns to fear their parent.” B. While spanking a child it is very easy for a parent to lose their temper as they become upset with the situation and transfer that anger to the child.
Spanking can cause the infant feel sad, hate themselves and become depressed. It may also cause trauma and violent relationships. Fox News stated that “Legislator from California was proposing a bill to outlaw spanking of kids under the age three (Estrich).” Would parents agree to this law? A parent argued about the law that parents need to hit kids in order to maintain discipline (Estrich). Parents can still maintain discipline without spanking kids.