Sophie's Joy Luck: a Look Into the Joy Luck Club and Sophie's Choice

2156 Words9 Pages
Throughout history families have passed down wisdom and life-lessons through the art of storytelling. Stories have shaped the moral upbringing of modern day society, and yet these stories are told in different varieties. Literature, film, and oral dictation are all forms of effective storytelling. The oldest form being oral dictation. Later then as society evolved the process began of writing down the stories began,and they have been told for many generations. Texts such as the "Odyssey" and "Beowulf " are prime examples of such works. Both began as an oral dictation that turned into an epic. "The Joy Luck Club" by Amy Tan and "Sophie's Choice" by William Styron show a fictionalized interpretation of the power of storytelling. Each book offers an unique look into the lives of the main characters, both the past and present. In "The Joy Luck Club" and "Sophie's Choice" the main characters use the art of storytelling in hopes of passing on a legacy worth remembering. When comparing both novels the most apparent similarity is shown in the influence of culture. The mothers and daughters of "The Joy Luck Club" share in their Chinese heritage, where as Sophie, Nathan, and Stingo are haunted by there Polish, Jewish, and Southern roots. The effect of these cultures are both equally prominent. Beginning in the novel, "The Joy Luck Club" , the main characters are split between the mothers and daughters in each of four families (the Woos, Hsus, Jongs, and the St. Clairs). Each mother and each daughter carry an important voice throughout the novel. "The mothers are all first generation immigrants from mainland China, speaking very little English and remaining cultural aliens in their new world"(Xu, 93). "The daughters are all born and educated in America, some even married to foreigners"(Xu, 93). The foreigners the mothers speak of are the daughters' American

More about Sophie's Joy Luck: a Look Into the Joy Luck Club and Sophie's Choice

Open Document