B. Leadership Handbook Scoring Rubric
Aspect Criteria 0=Unsatisfactory 1=Needs Improvement 2=Satisfactory
Articulation of Response (clarity, organization, mechanics) The handbook demonstrates unsatisfactory articulation of response. The handbook demonstrates weak articulation of response. The handbook demonstrates adequate articulation of response.
Score: 2 Comments: The handbook demonstrates satisfactory articulation.
Cohesiveness (consistent look and feel) The handbook is not cohesive. The handbook has cohesive elements but is not consistent overall. The handbook is cohesive and has a consistent look and feel.
Score: 2 Comments: The look and feel of the handbook is consistent and cohesive.
Overall Presentation (visual elements, report format) The overall presentation of the handbook is not satisfactory and does not include visual elements or a report format. The handbook presentation is satisfactory for some of the sections but not for the entire handbook. The handbook provides an effective overall presentation with visual elements and all articles are in report format.
Comments: Overall presentation of handbook is good, visual elements and document format looks good.
Comprehensiveness The handbook does not provide comprehensive coverage of the selected leadership topics. The handbook provides some comprehensive coverage of the selected leadership topics but does not include major content areas critical for a new manager. The handbook provides a comprehensive coverage of the selected leadership topics and includes the major content areas critical for a new manager.
Score: 2 Comments: The handbook provides comprehensive details for selected leadership topics that are critical for a new manager and the major contents coverage is good.
In-Text Citations and References in APA Format The handbook does not include in-text citations