Love Between the Poems

499 Words2 Pages
Discuss the contrasting views of love between the poems People always think love can be very romantic or exaggerate, but some of them are way too unrealistic. In the poems ‘The Passionate Shepherd to His Love’ by Christopher Marlowe and ‘The Nymph’s Reply to the Shepherd’ by Sir Walter Raleigh, Christopher Marlowe illustrates the Shepherd’s love to the Nymph by showing how romantic and perfect his offerings are. However, Sir Walter Raleigh is trying to challenge Marlowe by using “Nymph” to emphasize that the love of the Shepherd is not true and his mind will change of overtime, which also shows the attitude of them too. In the poem, ‘The Passionate Shepherd to His Love’, Marlowe is trying to persuade the woman to be the shepherd’s wife by using the repetition of “Come live with me and be my Love” (1, 20, 28). It shows that the personality of Marlowe is very romantic and everything is perfect with him. It also emphasizes that his dream is very idyllic. Marlowe also illustrates the senses to make the love letter become more effective. In the first stanza, he talks about the ‘hills and valleys’ (3) and it demonstrates the smell and the scene of nature. Also, he talks about the ‘wool’ (13) and the birds and the shepherd ‘dances and sings’ (25), which shows the senses of touch and hear to make the poem so beautiful. Overall, Marlowe emphasizes that the shepherd is idealistic because he wants to feed and appeal her by offering the beauty of nature. However, in Raleigh’s ‘The Nymph’s Reply to the Shepherd’, he is trying to challenging Marlowe that the things that he says are not true. When the speaker thinks about if the things are true in reality, they will “might me move” (3). This shows that she will consider about being together with the shepherd, but the speaker says “rivers rage and rocks grow cold.” (6) Raleigh also illustrates that the contrasting view of

More about Love Between the Poems

Open Document