"Let Teenagers Try Adulthood" Critique

551 Words3 Pages
“Let Teenagers Try Adulthood” Critique Since the 20th century, America has been the dominant force in the world politically, economically, and militarily. This dominance was partly due to the fact that the American education system was far more structured and effective than that of many other nations. However, Leon Bostein, the author of “Let Teenagers Try Adulthood,” claims that “the American high school is obsolete and should be abolished” (Bostein). He asserts that modern high schools in America do not prepare students for the real world, and the students are ranked hierarchically by attractiveness, popularity, and athletic prowess. Although his observations about American high schools are detailed and accurate, his analysis of and solution to the problems he proposes lack basic knowledge. Throughout the article, Bostein lists some flaws in high schools in America and expresses his views on them. He criticizes the poor quality of teachers and the education system and implies that the teachers do not care about the curriculum. Therefore, high schools fail to prepare students for the adult life. Toward the end of the article, he argues that students in America today mature much more quickly than they did in the 20th century. He supports this assertion by providing with a scientific fact that “the age of first menstruation has dropped at least two years since the beginning of this century, and not surprisingly, the onset of sexual activity has dropped in proportion” (Bostein). He suggests beginning education earlier and graduating high school at the age of 16, not 18. By the time students are 16, they are ready to enter the real world. While Bostein’s reasons seem persuasive, they are ultimately illogical. Although it might be true that high school teachers are not trained thoroughly, Bostein’s argument focuses purely on the teachers. He implies that teachers

More about "Let Teenagers Try Adulthood" Critique

Open Document