Lawrence Vs Texas Case Study

661 Words3 Pages
Mckenzie Downer and Kaya Carter Lawrence v. Texas Lawrence v. Texas, argued March 26, 2003, decided June, 26, 2003. A case that discusses gay rights and our rights to privacy. On September 17, 1998, John Lawrence, a gay 55-year-old medical technologist, invited Tyron Garner and Robert Eubanks, also gay, over to his apartment. In spite of jealousy, Eubanks left to grab a soda. While at the store, Eubanks dialed 9-1-1 describing “a black male going crazy with a gun” at Lawrence’s apartment. Immediately upon entering the scene, Joseph Quinn and one other policeman saw and reported Garner and Lawrence having anal sex. Garner and Lawrence were charged with a Class C misdemeanor for engaging in deviate sexual intercourse with another individual of the same sex. The law had been adapted to Texas in 1973. Gay rights advocates asked Lawrence and Garner to plead guilty, well aware that the attorneys intended to use this case to cause a constitutional challenge. Their attorneys asked the court to dismiss the charges against them on the Fourteenth Amendment equal protection grounds, claiming that the law was unconstitutional since it prohibited sodomy between same-sex couples, but not between heterosexual couples. They also asked the court to consider their right to privacy within their own home. On December 22, Judge Sherman Ross denied the defense motions to dismiss. The defendants again pled "no contest". They were then…show more content…
Do their criminal convictions for adult consensual sexual intimacy in the home violate their vital interests in liberty and privacy protected by the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment? Should Bowers v. Hardwick, 478 U.S. 186 (1986), be

More about Lawrence Vs Texas Case Study

Open Document