Is Karla Homolka Justified by Using the Battered Women's Syndrome

546 Words3 Pages
Mr. Zannata March 30, 2012 Battered Woman’s Syndrome: Homolka's Excuse Karla Homolka was the wife and accomplice of the infamous serial rapist and killer, Paul Bernardo. Homolka used the battered women's syndrome as a legal defense for her actions, but there is an abundance of evidence to prove that she lied and used the disorder as an excuse to lessen her sentence. Learned helplessness is used to describe a phycologic response of a person to the repeated unpredictable exposure to a painful stimuli. This may have been the case with Homolka, yet, as stated on a women's advocacy site, out of the group of women who are diagnosed with 'learned helplessness', only a very small percentage commit acts of murder or sexual assault. Therefore this disorder does not give Homolka an excuse for her crimes. While in the hospital after the beating that ended her relationship, Holka was examined by psychiatrists including Dr. Malcolm. He stated in his medial report: “She (Karla Homolka) does not show the instability, impulsiveness, and inappropriateness of a person with Emotionally Unstable Personality Disorder.” Dr. Long, a psychologist that also observed Karla said she was “technically of sound mind and free of disease of the mind of sufficient severity to cloud her awareness and cause her to be unable to appreciate the nature and quality of her acts.” Her dialogue in the video tapes and interview, her lack of visible injury until the end of the relationship, and numerous contradictions in her testimony all prove that Homolka's mind was working fine throughout her crimes. Homolka's lawyer stated that she experienced social isolation and threats of death to her family. However, Homolka did hold a full time job at a veterinary clinic. This was an open window to the outside world and there would have been countless occasions where she could have spoken to someone to get

More about Is Karla Homolka Justified by Using the Battered Women's Syndrome

Open Document