How Far Do the Sources Interpreate That France's Monanhcy Was the Main Problem for France in 1789 Essay
1239 Words5 Pages
How far do the sources support the interpretation that finance was the main problem of the French monarchy by 1789 There are a number of interpretations by the sources when considering the main problem of the French monarchy. One interpretation of this is the politicisation of the 3rd estate which is supported by sources (A,D and E). In addition to this, the King’s inability to rule (sources B and D) is another interpretation of the problems of the French Monarchy, as they show Louis weakness and his poor decision making. However, the noble privileges supported by (A, C and E) was a large problem in the French monarchy as they were extremely selfish with their privileges. On the other hand, none of these factors compare to the financial situation in which France, was terrible and is show in (sources B, C, D and E) , making this the most supported interpretation that finance was the main problem of the French monarchy in 1789. This is because all other factors of problems of the French Monarchy come from the financial problems that the Crown had at the time.
The evidence to support the interpretation of finance was the main problem of the French monarchy can be shown in source B where it states “lack of money has been beyond the French government’s ability to solve…revenue of 600milions, the King has declared bankruptcy.” This suggests that finance was the main problem of the French monarchy because they were bankrupt. This can be explained by tax issues in source C” We beg the king to remove the clergy the privilege of taxing itself, wanting it to be taxed the same way as the third estate… We likewise desire that all nobles be taxed in the same way in the same way and other privileged people as well.” The extravagance of the court is another reason explaining the bankruptcy in France. “The two privileged orders that still retained control of the government were